Mark Karpelès Opened the Ledgers. The Spy Chips Are Mass-Produced.
The chip that stole more than $90 million from Ledger users costs less than $20 to build, snaps into place with three solder points, and has gone through at least three generations of design. Whoever makes it isn't planning a short run.
Ledger says its own chip and software were never compromised, and that every confirmed case traces back to one Malaysian reseller, CryptoBilis. But implanted devices have also been reported from authorized shops in Singapore and from MediaMarkt in Germany, and Ledger had photos of the newer implant on its website months before the drains.
Camila Russo talks with Mark Karpelès, the former Mt. Gox CEO who now runs Karpeles Lab, and who found the mass-produced implant after buying a half-price Nano X on Amazon Japan. He explains how the board is installed, why he thinks someone is selling it as a product, and why weighing your wallet won't catch it. He also responds to Ledger CEO Pascal Gauthier, who said Mark's Mt. Gox record makes him no white knight, and argues that one well-placed warning could have saved most of the money.
So who is building these implants, and who else is buying them? Mark walks through what to check on your own device, why panicking is the bigger risk, the open-source antenna detector he's building, and why he still thinks self-custody is the whole point of Bitcoin.
"If you have a hardware wallet, it shouldn't contain a mobile antenna."
Guest: Mark Karpelès (Karpeles Lab)Topics: Ledger, Nano X, hardware wallet implant, supply chain attack, CryptoBilis, MediaMarkt, seed phrase, Mt. Gox, Pascal Gauthier, Joe Grand, self-custody, multisig, crypto security, hardware security
Ledger Wallets Were Drained of $100 Million. Is Self-Custody Still Safe?
A hidden implant read Ledger seed phrases off the screen and sent them out over an eSIM. Mark Karpelès and SEAL 911's Jonty discuss what that means for self-custody.
========================================================
Thank you to our sponsor!
Put your crypto to work with Nexo: earn daily interest or borrow funds against your assets on one platform trusted by more than 10 million clients.
Find out more at https://unchainedcrypto.com/go/nexo-podcast-sn.
Geo-restrictions, eligibility and terms apply.
========================================================
Quick favor: We're deciding what Unchained does next; new shows, stream times, what's worth paying for. Our listener survey takes five minutes, it's anonymous, and I read the write-in answers myself. Everyone who takes it can enter a drawing for a free year of Unchained Premium or Bits + Bips Premium. Open through Sunday, October 18.
— Laura
========================================================
An estimated $100 million or more has been drained from Ledger hardware wallets sold through CryptoBilis, an authorized reseller in Southeast Asia. The devices carried a hidden implant that reads the seed phrase off the screen and sends it out over an eSIM.
Jonty, founder of Pangolin Intelligence and a SEAL 911 contributor, and Mark Karpelès, CEO of Karpelès Lab, join Laura Shin to trace how the attack was found and how far it may reach.
They cover drains dating back to September 8, a tampered Ledger Flex bought from Metapod at Singapore's airport, the two MediaMarkt devices a buyer in Europe traced to distributor Aqipa, and Tether's $10 million freeze.
Mark argues Ledger's manual sends mixed signals by picturing the device's insides while warning that opening it voids the warranty, then opens a Nano X on camera to show what to look for.
The open question is whether self-custody's best defense against malware has become its newest attack surface.
Host:
Laura Shin, Host / Unchained
Guests:
Mark Karpelès - CEO of Karpelès Lab Inc.
Jonty - Founder of Pangolin Intelligence and Contributor to SEAL 911
Timestamps
🎬 00:00 Intro
🚨 03:50 How Jonty spotted the Ledger drains through SEAL 911 victim reports
📡 05:52 How the implant reads a 24-word seed phrase and sends it out by eSIM
🛫 11:33 Mark on the spy implant he found in a Ledger Flex bought in Singapore
🕵️ 15:16 CryptoBilis or a distributor? Mark and Jonty on who could be behind it
📣 17:38 Nexo: Generate daily interest on your crypto or borrow against your assets at https://unchainedcrypto.com/go/nexo-podcast-yt
🇪🇺 18:19 MediaMarkt and Aqipa: has the Ledger implant reached Europe?
🛒 27:00 Buying direct vs. through a reseller, and why Vietnam needs resellers
🔐 31:30 Ledger's 'tamper-proof' notice and whether self-custody is dead
🔧 36:45 Mark opens a Nano X on camera to show how to check for an implant
🧊 40:33 Tether's $10M freeze and why Jonty says recovery could take years
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices